One Small Change
Max McDonough
I was suddenly ill as the rattling bus
curved around the mountains’
repeating elbows
toward the distant summit’s tourist village,
last breath before three hours of ancient stairs
crumbling up to green ruins.
To steady myself,
I muttered the memorized fragments
of old poems. We look at the world once.
Taciturn, oblivious. I repeated them
for forty minutes or so, until the spell
expired, and the glass ball of pain
in the bloated cradle of my stomach
shook the poems’ grip on my clenched attention
and the passing rusts, grassy wavering of
pastures, cliffside, andenes, running streams
loosened, broke open, refracted
into something unexpected—
the rosary prayer I had finally memorized
in childhood, bead by bead, to protect
my hands from the volunteer mom
CCD teacher who paced stork-like
at the head of the classroom, surveying
the grid of melamine desks the color
of a flock of manila folders,
my legs already quivering
though I was just becoming awake
to my internal situation. She possessed
the expected vengefulness, slapping
with her neon-pink plastic ruler
the clumsy, unremembering knuckles
of my left hand (because she had seen
such a punishment
on TV?), the pale summits and valleys
of my hand deepening red and white
as the beads I should’ve known by then
how to pray by.
I had no such beads
on the bus, but the mossy geography
of the words of the prayer
like stepping stones surfaced
from the flooded landscape
of my brain where the murk
and water that covers
everything receded to issue,
after decades, in front of me
a path: Hello,
how art thou! who art in Heaven!, hallow
be thy, thy will be, on Earth, give us, and
then the classroom around the prayer
which had formed the prayer to begin with
formed itself again where the undefined
and twiggy gay boy I had been
tried with crayons to create
the illusion of his favorite color “tie-dye”
in the pages of a mass-produced coloring book
filled with handsome depictions of Jesus,
and soon-to-be tie-dyed doves
and tie-dyed execution crosses,
clenching his legs in a kind of prayer
in the absence of poems,
until, like a tragic sideways benediction
of food poisoning and bad timing
he, I, shit my pants, right there in the church classroom
as the faces of the surrounding kids changed,
as the teacher-mom oversaw
my legs squirming with the question
I would’ve asked
if not for burying it in my larynx instead
or, rather, burying
only its beginning, Miss,
can I go—my hand not shooting up,
knowing what I needed but still not
saying so. Then I remembered
I was on a bus, weaving through mountains
and the vision, if we can call it that,
finally compelled me to turn
to my friend who sat beside me, quite oblivious,
reading Nabokov how I imagine everyone
reads Nabokov by watching clouds
drift in the nearest window instead,
the book open in her lap.
I said, Please.
Which plainly meant, I am dying.
I was not dying, of course,
merely preferring death,
my body the object again, the soul
in this case
a thin thread in a whirlwind
having no business being where it was
though having no volition either,
so I relinquished
and said thank you for the prayer,
thank you for the classroom, the teacher-mom
and her pacing,
thank you for the poems that were the trouble,
the broken ringlets, the unbroken
surface of the pond of the poems
that bought me the forty minutes or so
through which the light of time
shattered and burst across the bus
forming the classroom of the Parish of
Elizabeth Ann Seton in Absecon,
New Jersey, reforming as the passing
of language to my dear friend
to the fluent couple in the front row
who convinced the driver to pull over
into one of the villages along the tourist road
where a shopkeeper, thank you, permitted
my Please, please, please, please,
my flinging open the door at the rear
for my sheepish body, which is living.
So much of growing up Catholic for me was about learning shame and pretending that I didn’t have a real body. My body was always getting in the way. The wrong desires and needs meant my body was betraying me. How small could I make my body? How well-behaved and quiet?
I tried inverting that in this poem. How much space can I take up? How long can I go on gabbing? What if said what I wanted and needed?

MAX MCDONOUGH'S debut poetry collection, Python with a Dog Inside It, won the 2023 St. Lawrence Book Award from Black Lawrence Press. His work has appeared in The New York Times, AGNI, Best New Poets, The Adroit Journal, T Magazine, and elsewhere. maxmcdonough.co
